Search Maine Yellow Pages 
Log In | Register | Help

From the Editor
Executive Editor Eric Conrad sheds light on our newspapers and our Web sites, on the role of community journalists, sharing news and perspective about the challenges facing the media industry, and offering insight into the frequent comments and contact we have with readers, government leaders and the business community.

Blog Index
September 10, 2007
College, private or public?

In case you missed it, reporter Colin Hickey did a good job explaining the reasons behind the escalating costs of a college education in Sunday's newspapers.

You can read his stories here:
Some parents find coping with college costs daunting

Intimidating costs can be managed

But I have a different question: Do you feel a private or public college education is best? There are several ways to look at this.

If you examine raw tuition and reimbursement, U-Maine and its nonflagship campuses cost roughly a third of what Maine's "elite" private schools do.

Then again, the private colleges will tell you they have nice financial-aid packages and hefty endowments. So really, they argue, they are just several thousand dollars a year more for most Mainers than a Maine public university would be, all things considered.

A note of full disclosure: I went to Shippensburg University of Pa., a Division II state college in my home state, and graduated in 1983. I remember it cost about $4,000 a year then, for tuition and room and board. My parents were poor but my grandfather was not, and he left us enough so I only graduated with about $1,500 in debt (I had part-time jobs all through college, and won one scholarship) after four years.

If or when you have the choice, will you send your child to -- or will you go to -- a private school over a public one, if you can?

I see two arguments here:

1. A public university is more like the typical workplace demographically. Unless you are trying to end up in a top law firm, accounting firm, or become a physician, to me, I think vying in college "against" those whom you will vie with/against in the real world is a plus for public education. I actually believe a kid who goes to a private high school, an elite college and then enters a "typical" work force is at a DIS-advantage.

2. But then there's quality. You walk on the campus at Colby or Bowdoin or Bates, you go to the events and lectures and -- if you're little ol' Shippensburg me -- you think, "Wow, this is really well done." As a father of two daughters, it's tempting to try to send them to the best I can (period), and see what happens.

Personally, and I've thought about this a lot for some reason, I'd go to Shippensburg again and not change a thing.

But what do you think?

Posted by Eric Conrad at 09:18 AM
Bookmark and share this entry: digg del.icio.us Reddit
Comments
Post a comment









Remember personal info?







Please enter the code as seen in the image above:



Blog Index


Bookmark and share this entry:
digg del.icio.us Reddit
Updates
Sign up to be notified when there's a new entry
RSS
Subscribe

Add to Technorati Favorites